“We know from chaos theory that even if you had a perfect model of the world, you’d need
infinite precision in order to predict future events. With sociopolitical or economic phenomena,
we don’t have anything like that.”
–Nassim Nicholas Taleb
Commentary & Analysis
The Fed’s Fake News: Inflation Risks. Buy bonds!
It’s an interesting aspect of the human condition—clinging to our view despite the fact reality has already invalidated them. The Federal Open Market Committee seems to have this characteristic firmly embedded in its DNA.
To wit, today’s headline from Reuters:
Fed policymakers agree Trump fiscal boost poses inflation risk
WASHINGTON, Jan 4 (Reuters) – Almost all Federal Reserve policymakers thought the economy could grow more quickly because of fiscal stimulus under the Trump administration and many were eyeing faster interest rate increases, minutes from the central bank’s December meeting showed.
Now, not to be too critical of this august body of Ph.D.-laced economists, but if you are on the Federal Open Market Committee it seems you should be aware of the latest research that shows increased fiscal spending when debt-gdp levels are already high doesn’t lead to inflation; but in fact adds to deflationary pressures for the economy.
I place into evidence the following from Hoisington Research; a fixed income investment management firm who is arguably the best bond manager in the world. This is from their 3rd Quarter 2016 Economic Review and Outlook:
If new fiscal measures are enacted, debt-to-GDP ratios will be increased and will further depress growth, thereby causing interest rates to move lower, not higher. In a highly incongruous development, governments will therefore be able to finance their new debt offerings at lower costs. While this may seem to be a good thing for the individual governments, the great majority of their constituents will be harmed. The higher debt will set off a chain reaction of unintended consequences. The 70-75% of the households that receive the bulk of their investment income from interest bearing accounts will have fewer funds for retirement. This, in turn, will cause older members of the workforce to work longer and save more, blocking job opportunities for new entrants into the labor force. Thus, fiscal decisions, which result in higher deficits, are likely to perpetuate and intensify our underlying economic problems.
Impressive scholarly research has demonstrated that the government spending multiplier is in fact negative, meaning that a dollar of deficit spending slows economic output. The fundamental rationale is that the government has to withdraw funds, via taxes or borrowing, from the private sector, to spend their dollars. When that happens, the more productive private sector of the economy has fewer funds to use to make productive investments. Thus the economy slows along with productivity when government spending increases.
Let’s face it. There will be disappointment when it comes to the Trump agenda. The Democrats will do all they can to block key parts; and maybe some of Trump’s own party will throw up a few roadblocks. And even if enacted, the benefits of tax cuts and regulation (which is where the benefits flow to the real economy) will take time to flow through. In addition, much of the benefits will likely be overwhelmed by existing debt levels and the increased drag from Trump’s infrastructure plans.
So, buy bonds. If the Fed is forecasting inflation, what better contrary indicator do you need?
TLT (iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF) daily wave view: