System Review: 4H Scalping Method

*beep boop beep beep*

Salutations, mortals! I have returned from my 7-day long stay in my pod where I conducted a backtest of the 4H Scalping Method by NickB. I have finished crunching the numbers and I’m ready to grade the system based on the Robopip Standard for Mechanical Systems.

Once again, below are the backtesting parameters:

Backtest period: February 2012 to July 2013
Currency Pair: GBP/JPY
Time frame: 4-hour
Indicators: None
Entry rules: Used the swing highs and lows as scalp lines and entered on the break above or below these levels
Stop loss: 50 pips
Profit target: 50 pips
Risk: 1% per trade

So, without further ado, here’s my take on the mechanized 4H Scalping Method system:


Profitability: 14/20

After going through the data, we can see that the system was profitable on 59.52% of its trades, which is above my standard 50% benchmark.

Moreover system was able to generate a positive return of 12% over the testing period. At first glance, a human may think that this isn’t too bad, but considering that the testing period is over 18 months, that gives us a return of around .75% per month, which isn’t too great.

I also find that the reward-to-risk ratio is a little small for my liking. The profit target could be adjusted in order to help maximize return-on-risk.

Risk tolerance: 17/20

The per trade was limited to just 50 pips / 1%, which I find acceptable. This stop loss strategy allowed the system to cut losses if price faked to the upside / downside of the scalp lines.

My one concern though, is that I feel a 50-pip stop may be a little too tight if we’re playing a cross pair like GBP/JPY.

Newbie-friendliness: 7/10

For the most part, the system is easy to understand, as no technical indicators are needed. However, I feel that there is a lot of grey area involved since determining scalp lines or swing highs/lows may prove to be too subjective. Newbies normally makes mistakes establishing swing highs and lows so this part might be a little confusing.

Furthermore, one also needs to be constantly watching the charts in order to anticipate breaks of the scalp lines. Some newbies may find this a little draining if they are just starting out.

Total Score: 38/50

Overall, I can say that it is a simple system. However, it is very subjective, which means it might be near impossible to duplicate another trader’s results. The reward-to-risk ratio can also still be improved. The pair that this was tested on was GBP/JPY, which is a highly volatile pair. A wider stop or even a trailing stop might have been better, together with a bigger profit target.

Like what you've read?
Join over 45,000 other traders who get our newsletter. Tutorials, EAs, chart setups, free forex trading systems, and more!

    Nice material to understand forex in an easy way.

  • Manikandan

    This is very useful material for all category traders including beginner, experienced Forex traders…thanks to baby pips

    • M FAROOQ

      yes Manikandan u told right.

  • sarahlucy
  • Damien

    Just wondering if you make your code available to people. I would like to do my own testing / tweaking with this particular one. But creating the code from scratch is still a challenge for me. Thanks.

  • sarahlucy